NATO review's current edition, takes a closer look on NATO-Russia relations and how this has been changed through the years. As Paul King says; looking at Russia and NATO like similar partners is like comparing apples and pears:
- Russia's history stretches back centuries. NATO is just 62 years old.
- Russia is a sovereign nation state. NATO is an alliance.
- And Russia has defended itself successfully from attacks ranging from Napoleon's armies to Hitler's Panzers. No NATO country has ever been invaded after joining
But Russia was the centre of a key old empire, the Soviet Union. And NATO was the West's counterbalance. Since the end of the Soviet Union, both sides have clearly stated that neither is the other's enemy. Both sides have increased cooperation. But, the question remains, does the shadow of the iron curtain still hang over today's relationship?
Overview of the articles:
NATO and Russia today: interview with Dmitri Trenin
Dmitri Trenin, Director of the Carnegie Moscow Center, looks at where the NATO-Russia relations are today
Taking the temperature: what the Russian experts think
How do Russian experts see NATO's evolving relationship with Russia in areas such as missile defence, Afghanistan and other security issues? Here, we present the results of a survey of Russian experts by the independent Atlantic Initiative.
NATO and Russia: doomed to disappointment?
James Sherr of Chatham House contends that different understanding on either side of the NATO-Russia relationship keep leading to unwanted outcomes. And until this bridge is broached, cooperation will not lead to harmony, he argues.
Dealing with the symbolic irritant in NATO-Russia diplomacy
That NATO and Russia are partners is not in dispute, argues Vincent Pouliot. The problems start though when it comes to defining who is the senior partner. And on this, a largely polite, but ongoing, disagreement seems to characterise the relationship.
How NATO is perceived in Russia (or lessons in optimism)
Robert Pszczel is NATO's face in Russia. The head of NATO's Moscow office, he now both talks about - and listens to opinions on - NATO's evolving partnership with Russia. Here he explains some of the feedback - and why it's positive to be an optimist.
Time to abandon illusions
Today is the moment for Russia and NATO to end seeing each other through the Cold War prism, argues Fyodor Lukyanov. Twenty first century challenges requires both sides to challenge of their 20th century hangovers.
One step forward...
Konstatin Eggert was the Editor in Chief of BBC's Moscow office for over 10 years. Here, he argues that the relationship between Russia and NATO will forever be defined by encouraging steps forward hampered by regular setbacks. But soon, other regional factors may become even more important.
NATO and Russia: resuscitating the partnership
There have been major improvements in the practical cooperation between NATO and Russia, argues Andrew Monaghan. But deeper, real meetings of minds about each other's roles remain elusive.